Blog Post

GLOBAL ANDROLOGY FORUM

Publications

Diagnostic value of advanced semen analysis in evaluation of male infertility

March 24, 2024

Article #44: “Diagnostic value of advanced semen analysis in evaluation of male infertility”

Authors: Cătălina Barbăroșie, Ashok Agarwal, Ralf Henkel

Andrologia. 2020;00:e13625.

https://doi.org/10.1111/and.13625

CAPSULE

Contributors: Donny Eka Putra, MD (Indonesia), and

Ria Margiana, MD (Indonesia)

Commentary:

Advanced semen analysis goes beyond the basic parameters assessed in a standard semen analysis. It includes additional test that can provide information about etiology of male infertility and prediction the reproductive success in couples trying to have spontaneous pregnancy or couples undergoing assisted reproductive technologies (ART). These advanced tests offer a more detailed analysis of sperm function and quality, including oxidative stress (OS), and sperm DNA fragmentation (SDF). The present article summarizes diagnostic value of advanced semen analysis, including most commonly used sperm function tests, along with assays used to assess OS and SDF in order to make comprehensive view of male reproductive health.


A critical gain of sophisticated semen evaluation is that it may evaluate male infertility in greater depth and nuance, so that a more precise and individualized diagnosis is viable, which may bring about customized therapeutic regimens that enhance patients' prognoses. However, A crucial downside is the heightened rate and intricacy of those methodologies compared to standard semen analysis.


From a clinical view, the medical integration of superior semen analysis has an awesome capacity for reinforcing diagnoses and remedies aimed at male infertility by identifying the root causes of infertility. Furthermore, modern strategies are integrated to fill the gaps left using traditional semen evaluation, providing physicians with a complete toolkit to realize the complexities of male reproductive health. Thirdly, the supply emphasizes the importance of standardization and continuous studies in advanced semen evaluation to set up typically identified procedures and reference ranges. This is critical for ensuring consistent and dependable consequences across different laboratories.


There are popular sperm function tests available: sperm capacitation and acrosome reaction, sperm zona pellucida binding test, hypo-osmotic swelling test, and anti-sperm antibody test. Additionally, sperm quality can be assessed by SDF test as well as tests that measure reactive oxygen species (ROS), OS, and oxidation-reduction potential (ORP). All these tests can help identify specific problems that could affect male fertility that might not be apparent from basic semen analysis. However, there are some limitations to these advanced tests. First, there are not standardized methodologies of these advanced tests yet. Second, the interpretation with these tests requires expertise and analyzed by qualified healthcare professional experienced in male fertility assessment. Third, not all healthcare facilities or fertility clinics offer advanced semen analysis, due to cost and availability of specialized equipment.


In the era of invitro fertilization (IVF), the role of advanced semen analysis became prominent. While providing detailed information about sperm quality and function, aiding the selection of the best sperm for injection, it is not always a definitive predictor for IVF success. The other factors, including female factors fertility status and embryology labs expertise, also play important role in IVF success.


Considering the importance diagnostic values of advanced semen analysis and their downsides, the clinician should interpret and integrate these essentials information with other clinical assessment (medical history, physical examination, hormone test, and other fertility evaluation) to design individualized treatment strategies.


Key Takeaways:

The article by Barbăroșie et al. underscores the importance of integrating advanced semen analysis techniques into the evaluation of male infertility. Advanced semen analysis provides detailed insights into male fertility, assessing parameters beyond basic count and motility, such as sperm morphology, OS, and DNA integrity, crucial for diagnosing and treating infertility. Incorporating these advanced analyses can significantly improve the diagnostic accuracy and treatment outcomes for male infertility cases. This approach allows for a deeper understanding of male reproductive health, enabling clinicians to tailor more effective treatment strategies for patients facing infertility challenges.

My Personal Viewpoint on Diagnostic Value of Advanced Semen Analysis

Dr. Donny Eka Putra and Ria Margiana responds to the questions by Ashok Agarwal


1. Could you share your personal views on the role of sperm function tests in male infertility diagnostics?


Dr. Eka Putra: In my daily practices, I do sperm function tests for patients who had unexplained fertility issues or inconclusive basic standard semen analysis. Because many patients can access information from the internet now, they often come to doctor and want answers to their “WHY” questions. In my opinion, sperm function tests should be integrated in daily practices for urologist or andrologist who concern in individualized treatment for male infertility. Even in the era of assisted reproductive techniques, we need “the super- selective sperm” to achieve the best outcome.


2. Is there a specific sperm function test that you trust and recommend to your patients, and could you provide insight into why you favor this test?


Dr. Eka Putra: I would recommend Sperm DNA fragmentation test, as well as hypo-osmotic swelling test and antisperm antibodies. Only these test are available in my practice.


3. What are your perspectives on the potential of new sperm function tests in the future?


Dr. Eka Putra: I think the integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) using algorithm to sperm function test data analysis and interpretation, can offer more accurate predictions of fertility outcomes.

Donny Eka Putra, MD: Short Biography

Donny Eka Putra, MD

Urology Consultant

Head of Urology Department, Dr. Dradjat Prawiranegara Hospital

Clinical staff, Faculty of Medicine Universitas Indonesia

Jakarta, Indonesia

E-mail: donnyputra8@gmail.com

ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-

Dr. Donny Eka Putra serves as a Consultant Urologist at the Department of Urology, Dr. Dradjat Prawiranegara Hospital in Serang, Indonesia, where he distinguishes himself with a cum laude in his specialty. Donny plays a pivotal role within the Indonesian medical community as an active member of the Indonesian Society of Genitourinary Reconstruction and currently leads the Urology Department at Dr. Dradjat Prawiranegara Hospital. His commitment to service extends to his position as Head of Community Service at InaUA and his membership in the Society of Genitourinary Reconstructive Surgeons. Beyond his clinical and leadership roles, Dr. Donny is involved in research, contributing as an active researcher with Team #3 in the Global Andrology Forum. His contributions highlight his dedication to advancing urological care and research.

Ria Margiana, MD, MBiomed, PhD: Short Biography

Ria Margiana, MD, MBiomed, PhD

Lecturer, Department of Anatomy, Faculty of Medicine, Universitas Indonesia

Jakarta, Indonesia

Email: margianaria@gmail.com

ORCID id: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6747-0117

Dr. Ria Margiana is a prominent lecturer of Anatomy in the Department of Anatomy, Universitas Indonesia, in Jakarta, Indonesia. Her academic journey commenced with a medical degree from the Faculty of Medicine at Brawijaya University. She furthered her specialization and pursued a doctoral program in biomedical sciences at the University of Indonesia. Ria is a member of ASPIRE and IFAA. As a dedicated member of the Global Andrology Forum (GAF), she plays a vital role in GAF's research team 1. Her academic output includes 161 publications, resulting in 963 citations, with an h-index of 13. Dr. Margiana's contributions to the field exemplify her commitment to research and education in biomedical sciences.

Share by: